14 Best Places to Buy an Engagement Ring Online 2021

Are you confused about whether or not to buy an engagement ring online? If nobody has ever said to you, it’s a smart decision to shop for an engagement ring online. Nowadays, many online retailers are committed to helping you find the perfect ring for your engagement.

14 Best Places to Buy an Engagement Ring Online 2021 pin

From on-call guidance to try-at-home experience, here we provide you a detailed list of 14 best places to buy an engagement ring online along with their best features and shipping and return policies.

1. Blue Nile

Blue Nile

Established almost 20 years ago, Blue Nile is considered the pioneer of the online diamond ring business. It is the largest online certifies diamond retailer that provides high-quality as well as GIA-graded ideal cut diamonds to their consumers at a reasonable price eliminating the middleman cost.

What’s more, Blue Nile offers a range of precious colored diamond engagement rings and also provides education and guidance option on their site for the visitors.

Blue Nile’s specialties

Whether you’re planning to buy a ‘ready to deliver’ engagement rings or if you’re planning to build your ring for your dream wedding, Blue Nile might be the one-stop solution for you.

Blue Nile is confident that they can either beat or at least meet the competitor’s prices and also offers secure financing options. Under the  ‘Diamond price match guarantee’ service, you also have an option of comparing prices of diamonds of comparable quality and characters.

Under the ‘Special order program’, Blue Nile commits to helping their customer craft the perfect engagement ring by offering expert guidance. It also recommends and offers its complimentary ring servicing and cleaning service every six months.

Shipping and Return Policies

Blue Nile is committed to making its customers happy and swears by fast, free, insured, and secure shipping including gift boxes and cards.

For orders above $1000 delivery, you even have an option of overnight delivery with Saturday with an additional charge.

Blue Nile is very flexible in terms of the return policy and accepts free-of-charge returns or exchanges within 30 days of the delivery without any inquiry.


2. With Clarity

With Clarity

Since many customers have vouched for this store in their reviews, With Clarity seems to have a history of providing easy and pleasant shopping experience to their customers. It offers GIA or IGI certified diamonds and many sought after gems in various shapes and collections.

However, if you’re looking for a non-diamond engagement ring this might not be the best place for you since With Clarity offers only 8 types of them including black diamond.

With Clarity’s Specialties

With its unique and praiseworthy home preview service, With Clarity has become a no-brainer for those people who are unsure of how exactly they want their engagement ring to look like.

With Clarity has taken full advantage of the emerging technologies and provides its customers an opportunity to try two of their self-created 3D-printed ring designs for 3 days. With Clarity is confident that the replica looks no less than the real deal and also offers free shipping.

Shipping and Return Policies

With Clarity provides free and insured shipping and also provides shipment tracking facilities. Typically, orders are expected to reach the customers by the 12th business day.

Except for custom-designed rings, With clarity accepts returns and exchanges without any hassles or questions if made within 30 calendar days of receipt. However, any purchase made from With Clarity within the next 6-months of returns will not be eligible for return/exchange.


3. Ritani


By offering 20-40% less expensive lab-grown diamonds as an option for their customers, Ritani proves that a wonderfully crafted engagement ring does not have to blow the budget.

With an outstanding range of price-sensitive designs, Ritani allows exceptionally convenient ring selection by breaking down their rings by setting.

Ritani’s specialties

Ritani offers virtual consultation with their gemologists in case you have any queries, or if you need help during the ring customization and diamond comparison process.

Ritani also displays an exquisite collection of ready to wear engagement and anniversary rings. On top of that, it also offers free engraving services to their customers.

Ritani has created its unique Ring Recommender tool which utilizes feedbacks of real gemologists and takes the budget and preferences of the customer into consideration to make ring selection incredibly convenient and budget-friendly.

Shipping and Return Policies

You can have your order shipped safely to your address, alternate address, or nearby Ritani partner shop free of cost. Ritani also offers discreet packaging to your orders to keep your secrets safe.

In case you’ve decided to return or exchange your order, Ritani makes sure to collect the orders from your doorstep once you reach out to their customer service.


4. Leibish and Co.

Leibish and Co.

When it comes to colored diamond engagement rings, Leibish and Co. does it best. It is by far the finest retailer of fancy diamonds online. Their engagement rings are unique, featuring brilliant-colored high-quality diamonds.

However, not all of their gems are GIA certified and the price range lies on quite the expensive side.

Leibish and Co.’s Specialties

Leibish and Co. offer 14 varieties of colored diamonds including extremely precious pink and red diamonds and also offer a lifetime warranty on their rings.

They also offer an amazing loyalty program that allows you to collect points on every purchase which can be redeemed during further purchases. They also provide gemstone, engagement rings, and diamond education for their visitors on their site.

Shipping and Return Policies

Leibish and Co. offer free and fully insured shipping. Once the final payment for the order is received by Leibish & Co., shipments normally take about 3-5 business days. However, items listed under 48-hrs are shipped within 48 hrs. after the payment receipt.

Insured and free return shipping is only applicable within the US.


5. Vrai


If you’re an advocate for ethics and sustainability, Vrai might be the best answer to your question “where to buy an engagement ring?”. Established in 2014, Vrai boasts its impeccable craftsmanship and sustainably created diamonds.

However, if you are looking for a wider range of collections, Vrai might not be able to cater to your needs. Also, Vrai does not allow its customers to select settings and diamond separately.

Vrai’s specialties

Unlike many other online engagement ring stores, Vrai exclusively uses conflict-free and sustainable lab-grown diamonds in its engagement rings. These diamonds are grown ethically using 100% solar energy by the Diamond Foundry.

Shipping and Return Policies

Made to order and Engagement rings are ships within 10-14 days of purchase free of cost. However, overnight delivery service costs you $50 within the US. Unless the purchase is above $10,000.

Vrai accepts both made to order and ready to wear engagement rings for return or exchange. For a full refund, the ring must be unworn, unused, and in its original packaging. Engraved rings are also eligible for return but the engraving fee is non-refundable.


6. James Allen

James Allen

With an extraordinary selection of over 200,000 diamonds and an eye-catching 96% positive rating from customers, James Allen is also one of the largest online retailers when it comes to engagement rings.

James Allen’s Specialties

James Allen 24/7 customer service including live chats, phone calls, or emails licensed gemologists is incredible. They are considered the pioneers of providing 360º high-quality videos with up to 40X magnification to their online customers.

They also offer free engraving options and provides a 1-year warranty on their rings.

With the help of a ring builder tool, they also let you select settings and loose diamonds separately to create your masterpiece. What’s more, they also have virtual ring sizer tools and videos to help you find out your ring size.

Shipping and Return Policies

James Allen assures fast, free, secured, and fully insured delivery of their rings worldwide and vouches that every order will have gone through the in-detail quality checking before shipping.

Original and unworn rings are eligible for return without any question asked. However, free returns are only applicable in the US. And Canada.


7. Gemist


One interesting fact about Gemist is that it offers both the website as well as a mobile application, which makes ring hunting easy and convenient.

Despite having a limited range of designs, settings, metals, and gem options, Gemist has played its A game by making the ring designing and selection process extremely easy.

Gemist also claims that the gems they use have an ethically sound and conflict-free background.

Gemist’s Specialties

Gemist has streamlined both diamond and gemstone selection and designing process. Under its ‘On the hunt’ program, they facilitate their customers with a 15-30 mins call with a gemist and they collaborate to design the ring they’ve envisioned.

Gemist is very customer-friendly and is fully supportive of the fact that its customers might be overwhelmed by all the sparkles and beautiful designs they see on the screen.

To counter this dilemma, they offer a full-on 2-weeks of try on at home service where you get to select three designs of your preference with free shipping and only a $45 deposit.

You will also get a ring sizer along with the try-on box which makes sure that your ring fits you like a glove on your first try itself.

Shipping and Return Policies

With 2-day shipping, Gemist estimates the try-on and engagement rings will reach their customers 1 week and 2-4 weeks after the placement of orders respectively.

Since engagement rings are handmade and custom at Gemist, they are not eligible for return. Nevertheless, you can have your ring resized at $45.


8. Aurate New York

Aurate New York

Though this site does not specifically cater to engagement rings, Aurate New York’s rings yell simplicity, minimalism, elegance, and class.

Not every girl yearns for a huge diamond engagement ring. If you’re someone who feels that Aurate matches your personality and might be able to deliver your demands, it might be the best store for you.

Aurate New York’s specialties

Based in New York, this store has an exclusive range of fancy and minimalistic diamonds as well as other gemstones ring collection. Aurate also offers a week-long trial of 5 ring pieces that match your style where you can decide to keep one at the end.

If you want in-store experience, you can visit one of their three stores in New York.

Shipping and return policies

Aurate New York offers free two-day express shipping all over the US. You can also ship your purchase overnight with varying extra fees that depend on where you live.

All purchases including made-to-order pieces are eligible for return within 30 days of receipt. However, Aurate New York does not accept engraved rings for returns.


9. Doyle & doyle

Doyle & doyle

Founded in 1998, by sisters Irene Pamela Doyle and Elizabeth Doyle, Doyle & doyle offers a limited selection of spectacular antique and vintage engagement rings.

Their hand-selected rings include wide varieties of eras including evergreen Art Deco designs, mid-century classic diamond solitaires as well as Victorian cluster rings.

Doyle & doyle’s specialties

They offer an impressive range of antique, estate, and vintage engagement rings hand-curated by Elizabeth Doyle herself under the ‘Engagement rings’ collection. The company does antique rings like no other.

Doyle & doyle also helps customers redesign their family diamonds. They also display an impressive list of cuts including old European and old mine and also boasts an extraordinary number of gemstones including Lapis, Coral, Amethyst, and many others.

Shipping and Return Policies

Doyle & doyle offer complimentary 2-day shipping and overnight delivery with an additional fee of $75 within the continental US., Hawaii, and Alaska.

If your engagement ring is under $2,500, you’ll have 7 days from the receipt to return the ring to be eligible for a full refund and 14 days if you want to receive store credit instead. Made-to-order as well as altered rings are not eligible for return.

For purchase above $2,500, you’ll have 14 days to return the product to receive the store credit which is valid for 5 years from the date of issue.


10. Brian Gavin

Brian Gavin

Brian Gavin is a 5th generation diamond cutting expert famous for his signature lines of ideal cut diamonds. Their excellence shows in their products which mostly are of limited edition and sometimes sell out quickly before you’d be able to make your mind.

Besides Brian Gavin’s signature engagement ring collections such as the 810 collection, Olympus collection, Truth collection, and many more, they also feature many other designers including Jeff Cooper, Parade, and Frieder Lauer.

Brian Gavin’s specialties

Brian Gavin’s impeccable skillset and extraordinary vision are core specialties of this store. Black by Brian Gavin features Gavin effect cut, designed and patented by Brian Gavin himself. Every diamond is either curated or at least approved by Brian Gavin.

Some specially cut extraordinary Brian Gavin signatures are their Hearts & Arrows and Brian Gavin Emerald. They also offer custom ring designing options including custom-cut diamonds and a lifetime warranty against manufacturing defects.

Shipping and Return Policies

Brian Gavin offers complimentary overnight and 2-day fully insured shipping for purchases above $5000 and $100-$5000 respectively. However, for orders worth less than $100 they provide 3-day shipping with a $10 shipping fee.

Custom, handmade, and designer engagement rings are not permitted for return. However, this company does accept Brian Gavin’s signature rings as well as engraved rings for return.


11. Whiteflash


With an overwhelming number of 5-star reviews from their clients, Whiteflash can also be considered as one of the best online diamond retailers.

Though it does not provide you an opportunity to design a ring by selecting setting and diamond separately, and to your surprise, you might not feel the need for doing so considering the array of top-notch designer engagement rings displayed on its website.

Nevertheless, you can create a custom design ring by providing your idea, sketch, description, or a photo during a custom design form submission.

Whiteflash’s specialties

Whiteflash is renowned for its line of super-ideal cuts called ‘a cut above’. Every diamond they sell is AGS certified. Their designer range includes many famous designers including Ritani, Verragio, Tacori, Vatche, Benchmark, and Simon G.

They also have a function in their site which allows you to compare two or more rings, thus, speeding up your selection process.

Whiteflash also takes its social responsibilities seriously and claims that they only entertain diamonds from legitimate sources.

With 100% of its profit coming from ‘Dreams of Africa collection’ going to the ‘Jewelers for Children’ foundation, Whiteflash is also vocal about its support towards some amazing organizations including the UN Global compact and Gravity light.

Shipping and Return Policies

Whiteflash provides free and fully insured shipping. Custom made or altered rings are not permitted not returnable. Rings displayed in its regular catalog are eligible for a full 30-days money-back guarantee.


12. Mociun


Mociun’s thoughtfully created designs stand out. If you’re looking for a non-traditional and unique engagement ring, Mociun might meet or even exceed your expectations.

Founded by Caitlin Mociun, the site features engagement ring collection, one-of-a-kind collection, and also helps convert your vision into reality via their custom design process.

Mociun’s specialties

Under their one-of-a-kind collection, Mociun displays you those rings that are made up of so rare and exquisite material that they were able to create only one. Rings under this collection are truly unique and elegant.

On your ‘Custom Jewelry Enquiry Form’ you can share your inspirations, ideas, budget, timeline, stone, and metal performances.

After that, you can schedule a meeting with the owner Caitlin herself where she acts as a creative guide. Together with Caitlin and the team you can final your designs which will come to reality in around 6-8 weeks.

Shipping and Return Policies

Made-to-order rings take 4-6 weeks to complete and one-of-a-kind rings take 2 weeks for resizing which will then be complementarily shipped to your doorstep fully insured. Nevertheless, the order below $200, the shipping rate is $10.

Resized, customized, and made-to-order rings are not returnable. The rest of the eligible purchases can be exchanged for store credit within 14 days of the receipt date.


13. Kay Jewelers

Kay Jewelers

Get ready to be shocked! Kay Jewelers features some beautiful engagement rings that falls in the price range of $100-$200 and a few of them cost even less than that.

If you’re looking for some Hollywood glam, you’ll love their ‘Neil Lane Bridal collection’ or if you gravitate towards softer and chic engagement rings, ‘Adrianna Papell collection’ will dazzle your senses.

Kay Jewelers specialties

On top of providing an extremely inclusive price range, Kay Jewelers features many collections including First light by Leo Schachter and Tolkowsy.

They also help you create your custom ring including the option of using different gold colors for ring head and mounting.

Shipping and Return Policies

You get free shipping if you are inside the US. and the estimated shipping date, depending upon the level of personalization your ring requires, will be provided to you on your purchase.

Except for custom-designed and engraved rings, all other items are eligible for return within 30 days of shipping. If you want to exchange your ring, you can visit a nearby Kay store within 60 days of purchase.


14. Kataoka


If your eye is fond of heirloom and exquisite rings, you’ll likely love Kataoka‘s designs. Founded by Yoshinobu Kataoka, Kataoka also has two stores, one based in New York while the other in Tokyo. In case you’re wondering, Emma Stone’s sparkling pearl ring is the ‘Kataoka Winter Pearl Ring’.

Kataoka’s specialties

Kataoka offers exclusive, delicate, and beautifully hand-crafted stand-out pieces. They also have ‘The Limited Editions’ collection that features vibrant gemstones and brilliant diamond jewelry including engagement rings.

Shipping and Return Policies

Kataoka offers 2 days shipping worldwide free-of-cost and fully insured. Since every piece is handmade with delicacy, the estimated time for completion is 4 weeks. Due to the very reason, all sales are considered final.

Isn’t it relieving to know that now you don’t have to run painstakingly from store to store to find your dream ring? Stay home, design the perfect ring and get it delivered to your doorstep!

14 Best Places to Buy an Engagement Ring Online 2021 pin 2

Leave a Comment