12 Places to Buy Diamond Stud Earrings Online

When it comes to a stylish and special piece of jewelry, diamond stud earrings are a great choice. But whether you’re buying them as a gift or treating yourself, they’re a significant investment. So how do you make the right choice?

That’s where we come in. A good purchase starts with the right retailer, and the choice online can be overwhelming. We’re going to look at where to buy diamond stud earrings, ensuring you get quality, value and style. And we’ve picked out 12 great online stores that offer just that.

So step this way to find a beautiful pair of earrings…

1. Blue Nile

Blue Nile

Blue Nile’s extensive collection of diamond stud earrings provides all the choices you could ask for. All types of cuts are on offer here, including over 300 round cut options. And rarer cuts like pear and Asscher are available too.

A powerful search function allows you to select your earrings by price, metal, and diamond cut. And you can choose from settings in white, yellow, rose gold or platinum. All gold tones are available in purities of 14 or 18-karat too.

A beautiful pair of round, near-colorless 0.25-carat studs (total 0.5 carats) set in gold will set you back just $220. At the other end of the scale, a pair of platinum-set round-cut diamonds of 1-carat each costs $34,000. Shipping and returns are free of charge.

2. Diamondstuds.com


As its name suggests, Diamondstuds.com specializes in diamond stud earrings, although they also offer pendants and rings. They guarantee the best prices online too, so you can shop with confidence.

You can choose from either natural or lab-grown diamonds, single studs or pairs. There’s a separate category for certificated diamonds, with accreditation from either the Gemological Institute of America or EGL USA. The latter is a more affordable option.

You’ll be able to select the cut of your diamonds and their setting (any shade of 14 or 18-karat gold or platinum). And if you choose a certificated diamond, you can choose every aspect from clarity to fluorescence, carat and the quality of the cut.

Prices vary from under $200 for a pair of lab-grown studs, to $600,000 for 5-carat certificated diamonds.

3. Super Jeweler

Super Jeweler

Super Jeweler are another site offering an astounding range of diamond stud earrings. They also offer moissanite, if you want the look of diamonds without breaking the bank.

There are separate categories for studs with a bezel surround, value options and huge diamonds, making it easy to find what you’re looking for. You can also search by setting – white, yellow or rose gold in 14 or 18 karats, or platinum. There are also filled gold and silver options as affordable alternatives.

Shipping is free worldwide. You’ll get a lifetime guarantee against defects, and a one-year replacement guarantees if you lose a central stone.

4. Macy’s


Renowned department store Macy’s offers over a thousand designs of diamond earrings from their website. And they include an excellent range of diamond studs.

There are a few pairs in platinum, but most are available in a choice of rose, yellow or white gold. More unusual options are also on offer, including stainless steel and sterling silver.

The selection criteria aren’t as specific as you’ll find on specialist diamond jewelry sites. However, you can still filter your search results by carat, setting and price.

Note that not all the diamonds here are certificated. You can, though, filter your results to see only certificated diamonds if you wish.

5. USA Jewels

USA Jewels

USA Jewels is a great choice for those looking to choose every aspect of their diamond studs. You can pick diamonds anywhere from 0.1 carats up to a lobe-straining 10 carats.

There are a range of beautiful designs too, from classic solitaires to clusters and halo settings. There’s even a design where the diamonds actually move, creating a unique sparkle. All diamonds are certificated by the Gemological Institute of America.

Shipping is available worldwide, and priority shipping is free of charge within the US. There’s a 30-day returns policy, and you can also upgrade your jewelry at any time. If you want better quality or larger diamonds, you can put the full original purchase price towards the cost.

6. De Beers Forevermark

De Beers Forevermark

Diamond giants De Beers offer a boutique collection of diamond studs via their Forevermark website. Choose your preferred style, and you can then select the setting and carat size. The metals available vary by design, with settings on offer in platinum, white, yellow and rose gold.

As well as classic solitaires, you’ll find halo and bezel settings, triple stones, heart shapes and crosses.

The prices are relatively high, but De Beers says their diamonds are the best of the best. Each stone goes through at least 17 selection stages before making the Forevermark grade. It’s then inscribed with a unique reference number.

Diamonds over 0.5 carats also come with a grading certificate from De Beers, providing the reference number and cut, carat, color and clarity. You can also request a certificate for smaller stones of at least 10 points.

7. Mejuri


Mejuri’s diamond studs come ready-made, so there are fewer options for customization than with other retailers. But there are plenty of stylish designs to choose from. Options include baguettes, round-cut solitaires, mini-clusters, bars, halo settings and wishbones.

Most of the settings here are in 14-karat yellow gold. You can also choose 14-karat white gold for a pair of large solitaires.

The pricing is competitive. Meiji claims their direct relationships with manufacturers allow them to keep prices low. Each pair of earrings has an “estimated retail price” of over twice the website price.

But take these comparisons with a pinch of salt. Although many of the designs include information on the clarity of the diamonds used, there’s no information on color. That makes it impossible to carry out your own price check with other retailers.

8. Bergdorf Goodman

Bergdorf Goodman

Bergdorf Goodman offers a beautiful range of both single studs and pairs from renowned jewelry designers. It’s a great pitstop for those looking for distinctive designs. Amongst those available are an “evil eye” stud in sapphire and mini diamonds, and a happy face in pave diamonds.

You won’t be able to build your jewelry from scratch, though. If you want to select the precise diamond for your solitaires, this won’t be the right option. But for unique diamond studs with the wow factor, you won’t go wrong here.

Shipping is free, and so are returns, which can be sent by post or handled in-store.

9. The Jewelry Exchange

The Jewelry Exchange

If you’re looking for a wide choice of diamond stud earrings, The Jewelry Exchange are well worth checking out. They’re also a great option for real diamond jewelry at bargain prices. You can pick up a pair of studs with a total carat weight of 0.18 carats, set in silver, for well under $100.

At the other end of the spectrum, you’ll find diamonds certified by the GIA and EGL USA. There are big stones too – a pair of certificated studs with a total weight of 4 carats costs $12,500.

The range of settings available varies according to the design. Depending on your preferred style, you can choose silver, 10, 14 or 18-karat white or yellow gold, or platinum.

10. Brilliant Earth

Brilliant Earth

Brilliant Earth allows you to build your ideal pair of diamond studs from scratch. Begin by choosing your setting, with the choice of platinum, 18-karat white or yellow gold and 14-karat rose gold.

Then move on to your choice of stone, selecting either round or princess cut. There are a range of designs, from elegant solitaires to halo and “secret” halo settings.

Both natural and lab-created diamonds are available, and Brilliant Earth have a focus on sustainable sourcing. Many of the metals used in their fine jewelry are recycled, and natural diamonds are ethically soured.

11. Tiffany


You’ll pay a premium price for Tiffany’s pretty blue boxes, but this is a retailer that’s a by-word for quality.

A pair of small diamond solitaires, with a total weight of 0.22 carats, costs well over $1,000. But these are perfectly matched stones, set in platinum. You won’t, though, find information on diamond clarity or color before you buy.

At present, shipping is within the USA only. It’s free of charge, as are returns. And you can return or exchange any online purchase within 30 days.

12. James Allen

James Allen

Visit the James Allen website, and you’ll be able to customize every aspect of your diamond stud earrings. The designs here are a mixture of solitaires in every cut you could imagine, and halo settings.

All are available set with natural diamonds (called “earth-created” on the website). You can choose between near colorless diamonds of F to G grades, or H to I. The higher F to G grades have clarity of VS (“very slightly included”), while the others are SI (“slightly included”).

Some designs are also available set with lab-created diamonds. Whether you choose natural or lab-created, you’ll be able to get solitaires up to one-carat each. And you can choose from 14-karat yellow or white gold, or platinum mounts.

Time to go shopping!

We hope you’ve enjoyed our guide to where to buy diamond stud earrings. Whether you want to choose your stones yourself, or you’re looking for a stand-out design, these retailers can help.

Take your time browsing, and check store policies on shipping and returns before you buy. But most importantly, enjoy your stunning new jewelry!

Sharing is caring!

Similar Posts